** Great opportunity to mock Farage today - the somewhat far-fetched North Korea comparison and some refreshingly spiky questions from Democrats in Congress have left the door open.
I have included some bonus social content ideas in the viral opportunity section.
This edition builds on the ‘Free Speech Special’ from last week which focused on the hypocrisy of the populist position on both sides of the Atlantic - hopefully a sign of how it may be possible to layer angles of attack and rebuttal over time.**
TL:DR?
What's Dominating: Farage tells US Congress that UK has "become North Korea" over speech laws - expect this to be spun as either brave truth-telling or dangerous hyperbole undermining Britain abroad
The Narrative Split: Progressive opportunity: Defend legitimate free speech while exposing theatrical exaggeration vs Populist exploitation: "Proof the establishment silences dissent"
Why Today Matters: Farage simultaneously leading British polls and seeking American cash while comparing Britain to a dictatorship exposes the populist playbook: claim to speak for "the people" at home while soliciting foreign elites abroad. Watch for this pattern - populists funding their "anti-establishment" movements through the very establishment they claim to oppose.
Farage's "North Korea" Congressional Performance
What Actually Happened: Farage testified before US House judiciary committee about UK's Online Safety Act and recent prosecutions for social media posts. He cited cases of Lucy Connolly (jailed for calling to burn asylum hotels) and Graham Linehan (arrested over anti-trans tweets). Democrats challenged his free speech credentials, noting Reform bans critical journalists from events.
How It's Being Twisted:
Right populists: "Brave Farage exposes UK police state to the world"
Tech libertarians: "This is why we need Musk's absolute free speech"
Nationalist angle: "Labour's made us an international embarrassment"
Progressive Pushback Options:
If emphasising proportionality: "Comparing Britain to North Korea insults actual victims of totalitarianism - we can debate speech laws without absurd hyperbole"
If focusing on hypocrisy: "The man who bans journalists from his events and called for banning protests lectures others on free speech?"
If highlighting manipulation: "Running to America to trash Britain when you're polling well? That's not patriotism, it's performance"
Key Facts:
Connolly explicitly called for arson attacks on occupied buildings
UK has independent judiciary and democratic elections (unlike North Korea)
What They're Really Feeling: Fear that expressing views on immigration (or even supporting Palestinian protests) could get people arrested
The Legitimate Concern: Some prosecutions for social media posts do seem disproportionate and restrictions on Palestine Action are widely disliked on the left.
Address It By: Acknowledge real concerns about overreach and inconsistent enforcement. Support clear, consistent guidelines that protect protest rights equally - whether for Palestine or other causes - while maintaining legitimate limits on incitement to violence.
Remember Box: When populists compare democracies to dictatorships, they're not trying to improve free speech - they're trying to make all institutions seem equally corrupt so their radical solutions seem reasonable.
The Winner: Farage's Freedom Bingo Card
The Angle: Create a bingo card of all the freedoms Farage enjoys while claiming he lives in North Korea:
Flew first class to America ✓
Has lunch with a President ✓
Leads a political party ✓
Hosts a TV show ✓
Posts on social media daily ✓
Criticises government without disappearing ✓
Caption: "Help Nigel complete his 'Living in a Dictatorship' bingo card!"
The Execution:
People film themselves checking off squares as Farage exercises each freedom
Create new cards for each media appearance where he claims to be silenced
Bonus square for every time he appears on TV to say he can't speak freely
Why This Works: Interactive format makes the contradiction undeniable while keeping tone light and shareable. The absurdity speaks for itself.
BONUS VIRAL OPTIONS:
"The Nigel Farage Guide to Oppression" Mock travel guide showing his terrible life: Morning broadcast on GB News, lunch with Trump, leading polls, evening tweets about being silenced.
"Clacton Constituency Office Hours" Video of empty office, phone ringing: "Your MP is currently: Telling America you live in a dictatorship"
For Farage's testimony:
Sovereignty angle: "British laws should be debated in British Parliament, not American Congress"
Credibility angle: "Hard to trust someone on free speech who won't take questions from critical press"
Patriotism angle: "Real patriots improve their country, not trash it abroad for applause"
Complexity Made Simple:
Don't say: "The Online Safety Act's provisions regarding harmful content moderation create tensions with free expression norms"
Do say: "We can protect kids online and allow legitimate protest without becoming a dictatorship"
Soon: More Reform councils debate flag policies - expect "patriotic pride" vs "divisive nationalism" framings
Prep: Have local voices ready who fly flags but reject extremism - they cut through the binary narrative.
This newsletter is produced using AI - specifically Claude’s Opus 4.0 Model.
It is designed to offer insight and spark ideas but not everything will align with your values and strategy - take what works for you and leave the rest.
It may contain errors - if you’re going big on something here then do double check it!
We are always trying to improve the content by adding evidence about narratives and messaging that work.
We also believe strongly that tackling populism in a way which also strengthens democracy and social cohesion requires a willingness to listen to and engage with people who see the world very differently to us.
Rootcause offers a suite of similar subject specific newsletters drawn from a range of new media sources which are personalised for our clients needs. If you’d like to know more then please get in touch.
Feedback is always welcome: [email protected]